29 - July 19th thru July 25th 1999,
Vol IX
Mr.
Anderson in the Press Conference:
" The Answer to the Attacks
on the Press
is to Report More and
More"
At the beginning of the press conference, Mr. Anderson said,
"We
are here to support Yemeni journalists at their request, and to talk to
the government to see if we can convince them that acting against the press
is against their own principles, their own declared objectives. Yemen has
had among the best records in the Arab world for the freedom of the press
since its unification, but it has recently changed, and it is sad to see
that record changing simply because there is an election campaign. This
is not the way a country behaves that wishes to be a democracy and to show
the world that it is an open society. We are very concerned about Yemeni
journalists. No country can be free and a part of the world society that
doesn't have a free press. Regarding the actions we have seen happening
in Yemen, they are discouraging and need to be turned around for the good
of the Yemeni society, and not to please anyone else not because America
or England or somebody else says you should do this, but because this is
what Yemeni society wants."
Mr. Anderson added that: "The government condemned in strongest terms
the harassment and threat against journalists and called on journalists
who are threatened or arrested to report those incidents firmly so that
they would be able to investigate. The Prime Minister told me, and I am
quoting him directly, that 'We are committed to the freedom of the press.
We are doing our best. We are ready to listen to any report of violation.
We are open to complaints and the courts are open.' However, he said that
the government will continue to file court cases against journalists and
newspapers who print what he called lies. Interestingly enough, he said
that the government has lost every case against journalists in the last
ten years which he justified by the courts' sympathies towards the journalists.
Again he would not promise to end censorship of foreign publications, which
he said is a matter of ethical not political considerations. Both the Prime
and Deputy Prime Minister noted that this is a transition period and that
nothing is perfect and everything needs time. As you know, we are here
because we are concerned to support our colleagues in this time when it
seems that there has been repression of the press which seems to limit
the press and its freedoms. If the government means what it says, then
we would expect to see such things become fewer and more infrequent. We
believe that it is a challenge for Yemen in this period of transition to
increase its freedom of the press, and not to decrease it. But it can not
establish democracy without freedom of the press. Therefore, we urge the
government to continue to move in the proper direction, to enhance freedom
of the press and to make sure that attacks on press, especially threats
and harassments by police and security forces are illegal under Yemeni
law. The government must take action to stop them, and we urge Yemeni journalists
and Yemeni newspapers to report all such threats and file complaints and
to cooperate with and support each other and report any attacks they are
exposed to.
"Attacks on the press are designed to make you afraid, to make you
stop reporting things, and the answer to such attacks is to report more,
to report especially those attacks, to file charges, to demand investigations
and to make sure that those illegal things are punished under Yemeni law.
This is for your protection."
Asked about his evaluation of the freedom of the press between 1990
and 1999, Mr. Anderson noted: "The CPJ has been monitoring Yemen, as
it does with all countries, since the unification. We have been encouraged
by the movement towards democracy in the first few years of the unification.
We think that was one of the most open and democratic nations in the Arab
world, which is why we are specially concerned that since the rebellion
and over the last few years the government seems to be withdrawing from
that commitment to human rights."
Then, Mahbob Ali gave a speech in which he welcomed Professor Anderson
to Yemen and also expressed his appreciation of the Alayyam editor-in-chief's
efforts to support this meeting. He asserted that without all the journalists'
cooperation there will be no progress in improving journalism and freedom
of the press. He also expressed his ambition that the Yemeni journalists'
efforts will be appreciated by the whole world, because democracy and freedom
of the press are twins; there can be no democracy without freedom of the
press and vice versa.
"It is necessary that you take that step and keep moving toward a
real and definite implementation of democracy, and do not step back. As
you said, there can't be democracy without a free press, there are no rights
that can be obtained unless the basic basis of free expression of ideas
and freedom of the press is obtained. We met with the Prime Minister and
the Deputy Prime Minister, and I must say that I am pleased with what they
say. They both repeated the government commitment to a free press, to human
rights and to democracy. They both condemned in the strongest words external
legal harassment of the press. He also told me that the government has
organized a forum to teach the police and security forces how to conduct
investigations while observing human rights, and that the teaching would
begin in September and October. These are wonderful words but we hope that
they will be proved to be a reality. If they are true, then we expect to
see a decrease in harassment. The biggest strengths that the press has
in a democracy is other journalists. If you take these charges seriously
and see that they are reported officially and demand investigations, then
you may be able to stop them. If you do not report them, then you won't
be able to stop them. Every Yemeni newspaper should report every case of
harassment, not only their own, but everyone else's as well. This is not
about politics. This is about freedom. And if the opposition newspapers
are not free, soon the others will not be either. So you must take them
seriously and support each other. We will continue to talk and be in contact
and if there is any thing we can do you can be certain that we will do
it. Mr. Anderson emphasized his point that, while words are good, actions
are what really count.
Asked whether there is an organization that can protect journalists
in Yemen, Mr. Anderson answered: "The CPJ encourages and assesses journalists
in any country. If you are attacked, file a case, and even if you are not
responded to, file cases again and again."
Elections
& the Plight of the Opposition
By: Mohammed Hatem Al-Qadhi,
Managing Editor, Yemen Times
The upcoming presidential elections are the main topic of discussion
and debating of the Yemeni people nowadays. These elections are of a pivotal
significance since it lays the basis of a democratic practice that will
help promote and flourish the infant democratic process in Yemen, no matter
what the result is. However, this first experience, where the president
of the state will be elected directly by the people for the first time
in the modern political history of Yemen, should lead to fair elections
and minimization of the mistakes that might arise on the scene. In this
way, we will be laying the foundation for a long-term future democratic
process, although I believe no democratic system can be built overnight.
In the final analysis, the presidential elections will almost certainly
not bring any changes in the power center, for most political analysts
see that president Ali Abdullah Saleh is stuck without a challenger. This
is because he is the nominee of the People's General Congress (PGC) and
the Yemeni Congregation for Reform (Islah), the two major political parties
in Yemen. However, it is not just that. Rather, he has no strong competitor
in the country, and most people see him as the man of the times.
After the opposition parties failed to convince either Dr. Faraj Bin
Ghanem, former prime minister, or Dr. Yassin Saeed Noman to be their nominee
for the coming elections, they fell out in tumult, amid controversy over
who else to nominate. The past few days have clouded the horizons with
controversial discussions and debates amongst the opposition parties, which
brought the dreams of their backers to ashes. It seems that the opposition
has not learned a lesson from the previous parliamentary elections of 1993
and 1997. At last, the tough decision was made last Saturday evening and
the opposition recommended Mr. Ali Saleh Obad, The Yemeni Socialist Party's
Secretary-General, to be their candidate for the presidential elections.
But, was that decision right and convincing? Is Mr. Obad able to strongly
compete against president Saleh? Or was it a bargain between the government
and the opposition? This is because everybody knows that Obad is not popular
so enough that people will cast their votes for him either in the southern
or northern governorates. Or was it because he comes from the southern
governorates and hence he will definitely and without any obstacles get
the parliament's okay, so that people feel some kind of a political balance.
We don't want it to go that way, for casting votes for the candidates on
the basis of their being from the south or north will put the Yemeni unification
in jeopardy.
I believe, as does everybody else, that Dr. Yassin was the man to compete
strongly, for he has a lot of supporters all over the country, irrespective
of whether or not he was going to win. But, he could surely have gotten
a large number of the votes, which would have at least shown the real size
of the opposition in Yemen, which is actually a help in our democratic
process. But the nomination of Mr. Obad makes the people feel that all
of it is a mere decoration.
Another point that has to be mentioned here is the very disappointing
and hasty decision of the Islah party regarding the nomination of the president
Saleh. The Islah was even prior to the PGC in announcing their nomination.
This decision might bring about internal division leading to splinter factions
among the Islah party. However, the behavior of the Islah and other opposition
parties highlights a real political crisis in Yemen, and that president
Saleh is the man to trust. The fluctuation of the opposition leaves president
Saleh as the man of the time, stuck without a challenger. Therefore, we
hope the president will take this chance to again breathe new life into
the Yemeni society. This is because his people are troubled by many problems
and pitfalls. Real political, economic and social reform has to start now,
and it is only president Saleh who can do it.
We will wait and see!
|