16 - April 19th thru April 25th 1999,
Vol IX
Yemen
TV on Trial
Media plays an important role in the different areas of the life of
the people, particularly in our modern age, where the cultural communication
between nations has become very close. In other words, it has a paramount
role in shaping the public opinion, educating as well as entertaining the
rank and file. In short, this age is described as the age of information
and media. However, the pivotal role of the media can be visibly noticed
in democratic societies, where it is honored with the position of "fourth
estate", for it works very hard to correct misdeeds. To make this easy,
the TV / RADIO media in a society like Yemen where the illiterate people
rate is staggeringly estimated at 87% and around 70% of the population
live in the countryside where the written media doesn't reach, is still
having a top priority in shaping the public opinion. The Yemeni TV is my
concern here. It is lashed by a large number critical remarks from many
people. I will leave the evaluation of its work to its audience, who seem
to be wholly fed up. Some people are blessed with the other Arab and international
TV channels, yet some others are still troubled by the terrible programs
of our TV. I should say that I am not interested in criticizing for the
sake of criticism, rather I have tried to see the Yemeni Satellite TV channel's
audiences' opinion of their TV. It is these people who can judge it well
and their constructive comments that might help improve its work if these
notes are taken into account. This is because the TV in is still monopolized
by the government which should either improve the performance of the current
channel, or let independent TV channels be launched.
In short, I talked with different Yemeni people who candidly and
openly gave their comments as follows:
1- Abdulrahman Al-Huthaifi
Taiz University
To call a spade a spade, one must say that the Yemeni Satellite TV
channel has made few strides ahead since it was established. But, there
are certain shortcomings which I think can be avoided easily if the people
in charge are willing to do it. The first thing is that some of its announcers
are not well-qualified and the result is a poor performance. What is unfortunate
is that if any announcer tries to distinguish himself as a talent, he/she
is taken over to another rich Arab channel.
Under the pretext of encouraging talented persons, the Yemeni TV is
unconsciously doing harm to our great heritage of Yemeni songs by presenting
persons wrongly called singers whose performance gets on our nerves, while
ignoring very famous ones who have made great contributions in promoting
Yemeni songs.
Another point is that all serials are taken from other channels where
they have been already presented. Thus only those who are not blessed by
the satellite can see them for the first time. This is a problem, for we
have directors and actors who could do wonders if they are give chance.
2- Rafeeq Musleh Ad'Dubais
Student
In spite of the improvements made by Yemeni TV so far, we have some
reasons that are separating us from it. The people operating the Yemeni
TV do not consider the audience at all. Let me tell you how. In addition
to their boring programs, they even say something and do something else.
To be more clear, they something announce that they will present a particular
program after, for instance, the 9 o'clock news.
This makes us wait for it, but surprise, we get to watch a different
program. What do you call this? Carelessness, indifference or what? Isn't
that disappointing and disgusting too? Another thing is that the Yemeni
TV broadcasts it programs to its audience in Yemen for a specific period
of time, they can watch it only after 2:00 p.m. which is completely different
from other Arab satellite channels which broadcast for both local and overseas
audience equally. Besides, some programs have a good start but unfortunately,
after some time they become boring and monotonous.
3- Nada Yahia Qanber
Student
In my point of view, the Yemeni TV has made some good steps recently.
This is if we compare it with how it was in the past. However, it is not
able to complete the other Arab and international TV channels. In fact,
it doesn't reflect the real picture of Yemen. The choice of the programs
is supposed to attract and draw the audience. Rather, the programs are
very boring and are not innovative. This makes people search for their
solace and distraction in some other channel. In other words, it seems
that there is not a well-thought out plan for the people in authority for
creating programs that could educate our society, which badly needs a real
information and cultural revolution. The entertaining programs, moreover,
are not presented in appropriate times. The announcers, who are not less
important than the programs themselves, lack many qualities that are necessary
for announcers to talk smoothly, easily and coherently on television. Watching
them, one really feels unhappy because they are not educated fully so as
to be able illuminated and enlighten the society. The reason is that most
of them join the TV through favoritism and nepotism, the two main headaches
of a country that has lost many talents.
4- Ibtihaj Mahdi Abdullah
Karate Player
I think that instead of talking about the pros and cons of any TV channels,
we should talk about the potentials and factors of success of any channel,
comparing it with the others.
Actually, I am not very much interested in watching the Yemeni TV for
longer periods of time, since we have been arrested by the highly delighting,
entertaining and diversified programs of the other channels. I believe
our TV could make some good strides ahead if it considers the following
notes:
1- The kind of decoration that is suitable for each program.
We find that in our TV no attention is given to this thing which really
affects the presentation and efficiency of the programs.
2- Another point inviting the attention of the people in charge
of our TV is that the announcers should be very qualified should they can
attract the people to our TV.
Unfortunately, most of our announcers seems to be unaware of how improve
their potential and skills. If one watches them clearly, he/she can notice
that they commit many linguistic errors. They can't talk easily and often
have to refer to the text in front of them.
3- Improving the quality of the programs and avoiding repetition
of very old ones which people are very much fed up with.
4- We also notice that the amount of news items is very abundant.
Moreover, the presentation of the news is very monotonous for they start
with the local news. In other words, they do not consider the importance
of the event or the news item.
5- Ibtihal Ahmad Al-Adimi
Student
As a matter of fact, when our TV started satellite broadcasting, we
expected that a radical change would take place. To the contrary, we have
missed a good many useful programs like Malaga Atalfazyon, Ikhtarna lakum,
Surah, Alam Ageeb, Akhtaber Malumatak Wa Gawaez, etc. which I hope will
be rebroadcast again. These programs delighted us a lot.
Our TV is plagued with many problems like the repetition of the programs,
films and serials, the huge amount of frequently repeated news items, inefficient
and unqualified announcers who help in raising the boredom of the audience.
To be more frank, I sometimes prefer the Second Channel which presents
useful programs. Even Al-Barnamaj Al-Maftooh has become very boring.
6-Nasim Abdulhafiz Al-Qadasi
Student
I think everybody who watches the Yemeni TV channels and other channels
can see the difference. Our TV programs are very poor with their cultural
and scientific content. The way they are presented is also very poor. This
make them boring and hence the audience starts looking for a better alternative
and, of course, they can find it on the satellite. Therefore, they watch
their own TV, picking what they like, but ignoring the Yemeni TV.
I feel certain changes have to take place so that our TV can live up
to the level of the other channels which have fully succeeded in conveying
their messages. That is, our announcers should be chosen from among the
elite educated people. It has also to be provided with some equipment like
cameras, decoration and light. New programs have to be invented. It is
only in this way that our TV can flourish and be a real media instrument.
7- Dr. Ghazi Mansur Ameen
Vice Dean, Faculty of Arts, Taiz University
I no longer feel interested in watching the Yemeni TV since I found
my solace in other channels which consider the interest of the watchers
and are conscious of the priority of the news items. But our channel does
not consider this matter. Another point which has to be raised here is
that language of the announcers on our TV is very weak and unacceptable.
They are also not confident while talking or reading. This makes the audience
feel disgusted to see such things and repeated language mistakes. They
sometimes give news items without photos, which means it might as well
be broadcast on the radio. A good program that has won my interest is Sahrat
Al-Khamis. But in some other programs, like Mann Al-Masool or Who Is Responsible?
we find that the presenter of the program speaks more than he should.
He wants to show that the government is not responsible for the misdeeds
while in reality it is. So, the Yemeni TV needs a lot of innovations and
amendments. It should also reflect that we are really in a democratic country
and that democracy is a living practice. The room given to the opposition
and independent thinkers and opinion-makers is not there at all. It has
never hosted people like Dr. Abdul Aziz Al-Saqqaf , Dr. Abu Baker Al-Saqqaf
or Mohammed al-Maqalih etc. Recently, we wanted to see why some of the
most famous journalists have not participated in the Journalists Conference.
We want even to see some silver lining, that there is an improvement in
the democracy of the media in Yemen. I think the media is a real translation
of the one-track mentality of the government. The only way out is the privatization
of the media in Yemen. The government should be liberal in economy, politics
and media.
8- Bushra Al-Maktari
A short story teller
I feel sometimes forced to watch the Yemeni TV because I have no other
choice. There are no other options easily available to me. Yemeni TV's
serials are frequently repeated and monotonous. It applies the policies
of the government totally, and it doesn't consider the interests of the
people. It lacks all the means of making its programs very exciting for
the viewers. It does not serve the society, since it is not interested
in discussing its ordeals and problems. We do really feel that it is not
meant for us. Sometimes it copies other channels even in their social issues
which are not necessarily like ours. I think only the ordinary people watch
it for educated people can not find the new information or interesting
and amusing programs that can quench their thirst in the age of information
and knowledge.
9- Dhya Hamoud Razaz
Student
First of all, I thank you for you have brought a very important topic
for discussion. We wanted this to be done by the Yemeni TV itself, for
it is only through such questions that it can improve its work. The people
in charge of the TV should understand that we are living in an era of information
influx where it can no longer exercise a black-out on information. With
the blessings of the other Arab and International channels which present
everything new, Yemeni TV is being left behind. On our TV, news items,
for instance, are very old and are repeated many times. Sometimes, they
even cut off broadcasting of a live program or match, like what happened
with Nasim's last match, to present an outdated news item.
I believe the Yemeni TV could achieve some progress if its announcers
were well trained and well paid. They should also pay more attention to
the question of producing local serials.
By: Mohammed Hatem Al-Qadhi
Taiz Office Editor
Yemen Times
|