05 - February 1st thru February 7th
1999, Vol IX
Ibrahim
Abdul-Habeeb:
"The law is the final
arbiter in our relations with the media."
Relations between the government bodies responsible for controlling
the flow of information on the one hand, and the media on the other hand,
are at best strained, because of the conflict of interest. That is why
the job of the Directorate General for the Press at the Ministry of Information
a difficult one.
It is this governmental body that is often used by the authorities
to pin down the press. More often than not, decision is external to the
directorate general, but it becomes the conduit to bring pressure to bear
on the media.
To
shed more information on the work of this department, Ismail Al-Ghabry
of Yemen Times spoke to Mr. Ibrahim Abdul-Habeeb Al-Khorasani, General-Manager
of the General Directorate of the Press at the Ministry of Information.
Ibrahim, 46, is a university graduate from Sanaa University's College of
Arts. He also has a long experience dealing with the media since he has
been on this job since 1981.
Excerpts:
Q: What exactly is the duty of your directorate-general.
A: The law regulates our responsibilities.
Based on by-law (95) of 1998, the main duties are:
1. To license issuance of new newspapers and magazines;
2. To review the performance of newspapers and magazines in
Yemen and report on them;
3. To inspect the contents of foreign newspapers and magazines
and regulate their circulation inside Yemen;
4. To inspect requests for ID cards by journalists;
5. To assess requests for opening media offices and distribution
points and to approve agency arrangements;
6. To ensure availability (to the authorities) of any foreign
newspapers and magazines that are not in circulation in Yemen;
7. To arrange and organize press conferences of the senior officials
of the state of Yemen, as well as for visiting dignitaries;
8. To coordinate with the legal department to assure a full
implementation of the press law and other relevant laws;
9. To perform other tasks ordered by the ministry.
Q: How do you assess press freedom in Yemen
today?
A: The main problem we have in
achieving a meaningful press freedom is the inability of journalists to
adhere to the law. Some journalists believe that press freedom is equal
to chaos and confusion.
IN my opinion, any right can only be exercised if the corresponding
duties are observed. In other words, journalists may print information
they can prove in court; otherwise, they can be held responsible for publishing
false information or at least misinformation.
Regarding an overall assessment, I can say that many of Yemen's journalists
do not have adequate training or even comprehension concerning their role.
They abuse their powers to achieve illegal ends. The direct result of this
is that many segments of society today look at the media with suspicion.
I can even say that some circles are beginning to despise the sector.
Our job is to curb such behavior and to reign in the few journalists
who are giving the sector a bad name. We tell them that they have to work
within the law.
Q: Some independent and opposition newspapers
accuse your ministry of trying to curb press freedom. How do you respond?
A: This is not true. The law is
the arbiter in the relations between the ministry and the media.
We do not mind constructive or objective criticism. We do believe that
there may be some shortcomings in our work. We would like feedback to help
us improve our performance. But, we do not think that sensationalism helps
anybody.
We ask editors and journalists to respect the principles of the Revolution,
the constitution, the laws and the supreme interests of Yemen. Beyond that,
they are free to write as they want.
Let me use an example. The country today is the target of international
terrorism and extremism. We expect all Yemenis, not just journalists, to
see that this fight concerns everybody. We should all join hands to stand
up against these terrorists and extremists.
I can give you another example. Nation-building requires a hopeful
and positive public attitude. The opposition media almost inadvertently
sows the seeds of frustration among our people. Issue after issue, they
simply push a bad and negative attitude as if nothing good or right takes
place in Yemen. The starting point for them is a confused notion of opposing
the ruling regime. While that is legitimate for opposition politicians
and their journalists, they end up being in opposition to the nation and
society.
What I am saying is that there is a double responsibility that journalists
shoulder. There is a responsibility to the profession, and there is a responsibility
to the nation.
Q: The new by-law issued in 1998 is allegedly
aimed at reducing the number of newspapers and magazines. How is that implemented?
A: It is hard to argue what the
intentions of the laws are. A law is a law and it must be obeyed, even
if some people do not like it. But, the by-law number 95 was issued by
the minister of information in 1998 in order to clarify some points in
the Press Law number 25 of 1990.
Let me refer to some specific articles in this by-law in order to shed
light on the limitations it imposes on journalism, as some people allege.
First, the by-law does not really affect newspapers, magazines and
newsletters issued by political parties and NGOs.
Second, Article 5 stipulates the financial requirements for any media
publication as follows:
- The paid-up capital of a daily newspaper
must be a minimum of YR 2 million.
- The paid-up capital of a weekly newspaper
must be a minimum of YR 700,000.
- The paid-up capital of a weekly magazine
must be a minimum of YR 1.2 million.
- The paid-up capital of a monthly magazine
must be a minimum of YR one million.
-The paid-up capital of an advertisement
newsletter is YR 100,000.
Third, Article 9 stipulates that any application for a new newspaper
or magazine should provide the ministry with a valid bank guarantee of
YR 100,000.
It also stipulates that the applicant should pay 5% of the project's
capital to the ministry in order to get the license.
It further stipulates that the annual renewal of the license entails
payment of 1% of the newspaper's/magazine's capital to the ministry.
The by-law gives the minister the right to waive in full or in part
such payments.
Q: What action does the law empower you to
take if a newspaper is issued without permit?
A: We do not have cases of people
venturing to issue newspapers without adequate legal cover. But the basic
action is to impound any such publication - by decision from the minister
- and then refer the matter to the courts. Article 107 refers to this action
as administrative impounding while awaiting a court decision. Furthermore,
the property of such illegal publication is confiscated. The owner may
refer to the courts.
Q: How do you see the growth of independent
newspapers?
A: I am afraid the record is not
a happy one. We now have many of these independent publications which falter.
There are two basic reasons for this:
a) They have an inherent financial difficulty. In most cases,
an individual or group are able to secure basic capital to launch a paper,
but they fail to generate a steady flow of income from the paper itself.
Thus, one issue comes out, and then they skip an issue, and so on.
b) There is a lack of vision regarding the business and how
it is managed. Journalism is a very demanding job, and it requires that
the papers have a clear vision of what they want to accomplish and where
they want to go. This problem is further complicated by the fact that the
papers are often managed by people who have many other jobs and responsibilities.
I now of some cases where the chief editor or the top person does not show
up at the newspaper for long periods.
Q: Let me ask you about a specific case. You
have suspended the circulation of Al-Rai Al-Aam newspaper. What are the
reasons?
A: Yes, we have put this newspaper
out of temporary circulation and there is a case pending with the courts
on this matter. The judge will decide.
The problem with this paper is that it publishes information it receives
from stringers without checking and double checking. Thus it gets in trouble
with the law because of the wrong information it carries.
|