05 - February 1st thru February 7th
1999, Vol IX
"Marriage
between relatives is a direct cause of deadly hemolytic Anemia"
Anemia can be caused by dystrophy, lack of vitamins and minerals. When
you get anemia you become very weak and will probably not be able to think
or work well. However, most anemias are curable. Taking vitamins and eating
good food could treat anemia. Taking good care of yourself makes you avoid
anemia in the first place. But there is one kind of anemia that is very
difficult - if not impossible - to cure. That is hemolytic anemia.
The unique thing about it is that it is mainly caused by congenital
factors. A patient with hemolytic anemia must follow specific directions
in order to be safe. Otherwise, it may bring about death.
Dr.
Saleh Ahmed Bamashmoos is a hematologist. He took his B.Sc. in Medical
Laboratories from Sanaa University in 1982. He received his M.Sc degree
in Medicinal Chemistry from Sussex University, UK in 1987. He has finished
his Ph.D. thesis on "Assessment of Renal Function in Yemeni Patients
with Glucose 6 Phosphate Dehydrogenase Deficiency." He will discuss
his Ph.D. thesis at Alexandria University.
To shed more light upon deadly hemolytic anemia in Yemen, I filed
the following interview with him:
Q: What is emolytic anemia?
A: Hemolytic anemia can be divided
into two groups:
1. Congenital hemolytic anemia: This kind is caused by defects
within the red cells; e.g., hereditary spherocytosis, sickle cell anemia,
thalassaemia, and favism.
2. Acquired hemolytic anemia: this kind results from:
a. An immune mechanism, e.g., hemolytic disease of new born- incompatible
blood transfusion, etc.
b. Non-immuno hemolytic anemia, e.g., hemolytic anemia due to direct
action of chemicals and drugs.
Congenital hemolytic anemia is more serious than the hereditary variety.
Q: What is favism?
A: It is a disease caused by a
deficiency of the enzyme glucose 6 phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD). G6PD
deficiency is a sex-linked congenital disease. It is more common in females
than in males. If a patient with this disease eats broad beans, or smells
rose pollen, or if he takes oxidized medicines, he becomes ill within a
few hours. Headache, dizziness, vomiting, and running high temperature
are basic symptoms of the disease. Later, the patient becomes very pale.
Q: Can favism be treated?
A: If a patient is not in a serious
case, disease symptoms disappear within a few days. However, iron compounds
are preferably recommended. In the late stages, blood transfusion becomes
necessary, and it gives a good result.
Q: Are there specialized centers for hemolytic
anemia patients in public or private hospitals in Yemen?
A: The Ministry of Health gives
good care to patients through providing Central Laboratories with necessary
reagents that help in discovering congenital hemolytic diseases. But still
there are no specialized centers for hemolytic anemia patients in public
or private hospitals in Yemen. They are treated in children's and internal
sections.
Q: Are there specialized doctors for these
kinds of diseases in Yemen?
A: There are very few specialized
doctors of hemolytic anemia in Yemen. However, internists and children's
physicians also can treat patients who have hemolytic anemia.
Q: What can patients do to avoid disease aggravation?
A: Patients with G6PD deficiency
must avoid eating beans and taking dioxide medicines. The Hematology Center
in the Central Laboratories gives every patient a card. This card includes
the kind of medicines and foods that the patient must not take. Patients
must show this card whenever they go to the doctor.
Q: Are there any factors related to the Yemeni
society that cause this deadly disease?
A: Yes. Marriage between relatives
is a direct reason behind hemolytic anemia, especially when both parents
have the congenital factor. This kind of marriage is the most common in
Yemen to date.
By: Nadwa Al-Dawsari,
Yemen Times
Health
Sector Problem
Analysis in Yemen
a. Deficiencies of the Present System:
The Ministry of Public Health (MoPH) has identified six core system
input deficiencies which must be addressed if health care is to improve
significantly. Each of these core issues will be directly addressed by
the reforms. These issues are as follows:
Inadequate Management Systems:
This is the key problem of the health system. The current management
system suffers from overcomplicated bureaucratic procedures, a poor match
between resources and program needs, an inability to control the private
use of vital public resources such as vehicles, an inability to enforce
its lack of incentives to its employees for service improvement and a lack
of innovation. The result of these management systems is low output, inefficient
use of resources, lack of quality, lack of innovation and lack of sustainability.
Low Government Budgetary Allocation to the Health Sector:
The Yemeni health care consumer pays 75% of his/ her health care costs,
with government meeting 25%. Without a larger share of government allocations,
the MoPH will be seriously crippled in any efforts it makes to improve
health care, especially for the poor. As such, the health sector share
of the budget needs to increase. At the same time, the previously intended
scope of MoPH services is too large to be affordable by government, even
with a greatly enlarged budget. The Ministry must redefine its role and
target its services in order to best serve the needs of the population,
while handing over some financial and services delivery responsibility
to the private sector, NGOs, and the public at large, especially those
who can afford to pay for health care. In addition, it must phase its expansion
at a realistic pace which takes into account budgetary limitations.
Inefficient use of resources
A management issue of particular importance is the irrational distribution
and use of resources, which has led to inefficiency and waste. Health manpower
and physical infrastructure have expanded rapidly in recent years without
a similar increase in budget. This has resulted in wastage of the hardware
of the system, with low patient to health care provider ratios, and low
health facility usage. In addition, the current health system model results
in the lack of outreach services and over-dependence on stationary care
facilities. This is an unrealistic strategy given the geography and level
of health care awareness of the population of Yemen. The geographic dispersal
of the population means that they cannot easily reach these stationary
facilities for all their needs, and low health awareness means that many
remain unaware of the need for preventive and early curative services,
and as such need a proactive health service. Also the system has not been
able to put in place or enforce a rational allocation of resources, with
some parts of the country without health facilities and staff, and other
with too many. In particular, resources are over-allocated to urban areas.
Finally, the system has encouraged over-allocation of curative over preventive
services. These inefficiencies create heavy financial burdens on the system
with minimal gains.
Over centralization of Budgetary and Planning Process,
With Poor Community Involvement
The MoPH has made important gains in the decentralization process,
by decentralizing the budget as well as decision-making in a number of
areas. However, over-centralization of a number of tasks remains, which
creates inefficiency in health services delivery, and lack of commitment
and responsibility at the level of the service provider. While district
level health staff are ideally placed to understand the health needs of
the population and to plan for their needs, district health system structures
which could make use of this expertise are not in place. Instead, planning
financing and supervision of district and sub-district health facilities
are managed at a distance from the governorate and national level, leading
to many gaps and inefficiencies in service provision. In addition, community
involvement is nearly absent except in terms of payment for services.
Government Policies Outside the MoPH which Have Impact on the Health
Sector
Beside lack of adequate budgetary allocations to the health sector,
two essential issues outside the MoPH hinder the ability of the Ministry
to improve its health care delivery system. These are civil service policies
(Ministry of Civil Services) and cumbersome financial guidelines (Ministry
of Finance). Civil service policies set salaries below a living wage, forcing
public service employees to divide their time between their government
jobs and the competing private sector; the mix of civil service employees
is incomplete at the administrative and service delivery level; remuneration
for overtime and travel is inadequate; gross overstaffing occurs at some
facilities, at some levels, and for some categories of staff, creating
a huge drain on the health sector budget with very little benefit; and
incentives and policies to encourage staff re-location in needy rural areas
do not exist. The government's current Civil Service Reform Program is
expected to address some of these issues, but will need a strong lobbying
effort by MoPH in order to meet the special staffing needs for health.
In terms of financial systems, non-transparent and excessively complicated
financial procedures cripple the administrative and health service delivery
function, with even small items requiring numerous signatures and several
days to several months of follow-up in order to process. The Ministry of
Finance policy of awarding incentives to its employees if they return part
of the budget unspent each year create a further reason to delay the budget.
In addition, the budget is assigned primarily on a historical basis, with
lack of rational links between level of financial resources and program
needs. Both civil service and financial guidelines will need significant
reform in order to make them responsive to the needs of a functioning health
sector.
Inefficient Use of Donor Input
The health sector has been the recipient of significant donor resources
over the past 20 to 30 years. However, much of this donor input has been
wasted. While the hardware provided by donors such as buildings and equipment
has tended to remain within the health care system, and training support
has resulted in significant amounts of health manpower being put in place,
the systems set up by donors have disappeared. This is due, primarily,
to lack of an effective and cohesive national strategy into which donor
inputs could be set. Coordination among donors has also been weak. Donors
have been allowed to carry out their projects in isolation without a mechanism
to sustain these inputs and to incorporate them into a cohesive system.
This has resulted in low sustainability of donor projects, and low benefit
to the health system as a whole. Another key cause of low sustainability
of donor projects is lack of long-term coordination of finances to projects.
b. Effects of Deficiencies
As a result of these system input problems, the following system output
deficiencies have resulted:
- Low access to health services
- Low efficiency
- Low quality of services
- Low staff of motivation
- Lack of accountability
- Corruption and leakage of resources out
of the public sector
- Lack of sustainability
- Lack of innovation
From "Health Sector Reform in the
Republic of Yemen", Volume One,
Published in December, 1998
|