04 - January 25th thru January 31st
1999, Vol IX
Medical
& Pharmaceutical Products:
CHALLENGES OF THE FUTURE
1. Brief History of Medical & Pharmaceutical Trade:
Since the British colonial system started in Aden, on January 19th,
1839, trade between most of the Yemeni hinterland and the United Kingdom
started and grew. First, under the East India Company and later through
a multiple of channels, exports from London and Cardiff to Yemeni coastal
territories increased in all fields of business, especially medical and
pharmaceutical products.
The
British encouraged their medical and pharmaceutical companies, as sole
agents and/or distributors, to spread medical and pharmaceutical technologies
into Arabia through their base of Aden. Quickly, a profitable business
flourished.
By the mid-20th century, relations between the Britain and the Crown
Colony of Aden blossomed. The marketing of pharmaceutical products was
organized according to British Medical standards and Boards, thus giving
Aden a reputable place. Many local traders and companies started to handle
the businesses since the 1940's within the colonial system as general distributors
and agents. These include the Orient Pharmacy, A. Besse International Group,
and Al-Shifa'a Store, etc.
The Reign of the Black Market:
With the departure of the British system, and given that it was not
replaced with any system - let alone a better one, pharmaceutical services
began to face a serious problem. The lack of controls and adequate supervision
quickly brought in black markets in which quality was no longer subject
to any check. The phenomenon of black markets continued to grow during
Republican Yemen, and even more so since the reunification of Yemen.
All values and standards were eroded as illegal business deals were
concluded. Corruption quickly made its mark on the business, and continues
to strangle-hold this sector. One of the most common features of black
markets is smuggling in of expired or sub-standard goods, over-pricing,
and bad storage facilities. Often, these lawbreakers avoid the payment
of any taxes and other dues.
Smugglers usually bring products across borders, without the knowledge
of relevant authorities. In other words, their products might threaten
the health of users. Often, senior power centers, or fat cats - such as
senior bureaucrats, tribal sheikhs, and high-ranking security and military
officers- are implicated in the business. They accept bribes in return
for which they provide cover and facilitate the crime.
In the import of pharmaceuticals, observers estimate that more than
half of the business volume is carried out through smuggling. This puts
the nation at risk because the drugs are sub-standard. It also deprives
the state from revenue from customs and taxes.
Legal Markets:
The laws of the Republic of Yemen provide equal chances to all citizens
dealing in medical, pharmaceutical, and general trade. Under the policy
of full and open competition, people engage in the business of their choice.
After May 22nd, 1990, a new system was introduced by republican decrees,
which are based on decisions made by the Ministry of Public Health and
the Supreme Board for Drugs & Medical Appliances. Four years later,
in 1994, the government issued a guideline called the Yemen Drugs Index.
This is a medical and pharmaceutical registration for almost all foreign,
Arab and local medical goods legalized for importation and sale in Yemen.
The guideline offers the following ATC classifications under which all
medical goods are imported.
1. Alimentary Tract and Metabolism.
2. Blood and Blood-forming Organs.
3. Cardiovascular System.
4. Dermatologicals.
5. Genito-urinary System and Sex Hormones.
6. Systematic Hormonal Preparations, excluding Sex Hormones.
7. General Anti-infectives, Systematic.
8. Anti-Neo-Plastic & Immunosuppressive Drugs.
9. Musculo-Skeletal System.
10. Central Nervous System.
11. Anti Parasitic Products.
12. Respiratory System
13. Sensory Organs.
14. Various other organs
15. Medical Appliances
Many pharmacists think that, the registered drugs are not sufficient
in number, although the number had reached over 12,900 items licensed to
be imported until January 1st, 1999, in the Republic of Yemen. Half of
the items registered are circulated and available in stock markets.
The Yemen National Drug Company (YEDCO) produces 55 kinds of medicines
to meet the needs of the local society with proper-quality treatment and
less cost. The number of foreign and Arab manufacturing firms exporting
medicine to the Yemeni market is around 320 companies. Yemeni agents and
sole distributors are more or less 100 local merchandising firms specialized
in importing pharmaceuticals, perfumes, cosmetics and sanitary products.
Generic names used in Yemen markets might reach 750, while trade names
reached roughly 3200. The United States and Europe provide Yemen with most
of its high-quality products and services, while other products come from
India, Egypt, and other countries.
Producing Drugs:
Usually, pharmaceutical products gain ground in countries which become
famous for chemical laboratory testing facilities and capabilities. The
two activities feed on each other and complement each other. It is nearly
impossible for backward societies to make a real presence in this field
because of the scientific knowledge and skills required. Of course, it
is possible to import - a turn-key basis - plants to produce drugs and
other medical needs. But that is limited to packaging, mixing and filling
of ready-made or nearly ready-made products.
In some cases, some products can be produced under license. This requires
continued surveillance and control by the company which holds the trade
mark.
In the Republic of Yemen, it is possible to meet up to 20% of local consumption
through local manufacture, while the bulk of the requirement will have
to be imported.
Distribution of drugs, like any other goods, depend on effective advertisements
Mass Media is a direct and efficient way to make consumers aware of
any product. Television, radio, newspapers, and magazines play a great
role in consumers' tastes and orientation. Most people spend their time
watching or reading special programs, which change public opinion. Other
forms of advertisement use flyers, posters, placards, and even prizes.
Advertisement use exciting and stimulating methods to attract people
to a certain behavior. Hence, some medicines are sold more than others,
not because they are superior, though they could be, but because of a larger
advertising budget.
Intangible Assets:
Usually, intangible assets affect the performance and movement of imported
medical and pharmaceutical goods. The most important is the reputation
of a company and its products, and the perception of users. As people usually
spend a lot of their income on medical needs, many marketing agencies pay
enormous attention to the image of the products they sell. Factors affecting
the image of a product include:
1. Trade Marks & Patents:
Manufacturers are quite keen on the trade marks and patents of their
products. Sometimes, goods are more known by such symbols than by the chemical
components. Manufacturers rarely give exclusive rights to produce and
sell goods of their products. Such rights are granted on the basis of lengthy
legal arrangements.
2. Copyrights:
The exclusive right to publish and sell a literary, artistic, or musical
composition is granted by a copyright. Copyrights are issued by the U.S.
government and extended for 50 years beyond the concerned person's death.
3. Goodwill:
In business, goodwill refers to an intangible asset of a business that
is created from such favorable factors as location, product quality, reputation,
and managerial skill. Goodwill allows a business to earn a rate of return
on its investment that is often in excess of the normal rate for other
firms in the same business.
Policy Measures:
Today, the Republic of Yemen needs to take some visible steps in streamlining
this sector. The following steps seem appropriate:
1. Ministerial Quality Control:
The government in general, and the Ministry of Health in particular,
should approve certain standards for medical products. Though pricing should
be left to the market, quality and standards must be guided by certain
controls.
2. Prescription Supervision:
Many harmful drugs are sold over the counter. The authorities have
to control the dispensing of drugs to the public. All kinds of medical/pharmaceutical
products should be obtained from pharmacies by medical prescriptions only.
Of course, this does not apply to ordinary medical products such as
Febs, Tussils, Strepsils, Lomotil, etc.
3. Encouraging Competition:
Given that some companies achieve breakthroughs and advanced research
results earlier than others, the industry is subject to bottlenecks in
competition leading to monopolies or at least oligopolies. It is up to
the authorities to smooth this out by encouraging more fair and even competition.
The Supreme Board for Drugs & Medical Appliances in Yemen has the
role of ensuring adequate supplies of medical needs.
4. New Projects in Medical & Pharmaceutical Industries:
The medical industry in Yemen is basically limited to YEDCO. Although
there are giant importers, they have not ventured into production. I spoke
with one key businessman and I barely put the question when he gushed out
complaints about corruption and government mismanagement. "Most officials
want to rob you by proposing to join as partners simply because they would
allow you to proceed with it."
This explains why many would-be investors have refrained from investing.
5. Low Taxation, Tariffs & Customs on Medical and Pharmaceutical
Products:
Medical and pharmaceutical products are essential goods. Hence, the
Yemeni government has decided to levy no/low taxes, tariffs, and customs
duty on them. This policy takes into account the low income of the Yemeni
society and the draconian health needs in the country.
6. Government Health Facilities:
Government health facilities are in poor shape It was a wise decision
to empower the private sector to come in and provide the service. Allocations
by the government are less than 4% of the budget. This means health is
not a high priority, which is puzzling given the needs of society.
Conclusion:
The medical and pharmaceutical sector badly needs better management
based on clear policy objectives and priorities. Most of the world gives
health-related issues top priority because the growth of any nation depends
directly on a healthy and knowledgeable population.
Yemen has a lot of social problems, which cannot be solved easily.
Scarcity of resources does not make the job easy. But better management
of existing resources will go a long way in helping alleviate the current
difficulties.
The Republic can mobilize support from regional and international organizations
as well as bilateral donors. In addition, Yemen needs to mobilize the private
sector, which can be a source for large investments.
I am optimistic regarding the possibilities for the future. They say,
"Necessity is the mother of invention." As we approach the next
millennium, we can improve our medical service delivery system. It is not
just a matter of resources, it is a matter of efficiency of the system.
By: Ghassan Al-Ahdal,
Yemen Times
|