29 - July 17th thru July 21st 2000,
Vol X


Samir
Al-Yusufi to Yemen Times:
"The case has definitely
taken other dimensions which are neither logical, nor related to Islam,
but are rather political."
Mr.
Samir Al-Yusufi, chief editor of the Al-Thaqafiah newspaper is an experienced
journalist and learned author. He is fond of dialectics, stubborn and biased
in favor of freedom of thought. He wanted to make Al-Thaqafiah a leading
example of freedom of opinion and thought.
Nowadays, Al-Yusufi has become the talk of Islamic leaders in mosques,
demanding his arrest and punishment. Although he apologized twice, he has
been arrested. He was released after the interference of the Minister of
Information who threatened resignation from the Ministry if Samir stayed
in prison. Jalal Al-Sharaabi of the Yemen Times met with him and filed
the following:
Excerpts:
Q: A great war was raised against you by the
mosque preachers and everywhere, how did the story begin?
A: In the beginning, I never wished
that this thing would happen. Firstly, because the aim of this thing seems
different from that proposed in mosques and streets. As for how it started,
as far as my information goes, it started in the parliament provoked through
one of the Islamic parties in Yemen. The issue was put forth for discussion
and signatures were collected from other parties. The issue was then taken
to the general attorney . On that same day I got a phone call from the
general secretary of Islah party Mr. Mohammed Alyadoomi, questioning about
what was published in the Al-Thaqafiah newspaper about the novel 'Sana
Madina Maftuha' which he vowed for the atheist Mohammed Abdulwali and tried
to get a straight confession from me about the reasons for publishing the
matter. In his opinion, this newspaper should not have published that story.
I replied that this book is already published and circulated in the markets
and had been printed more than six times with permission from the Ministry
of Information but he ignored this aspect and threatened that he would
treat me right and will raise the case to the highest level of the presidency
and the government and kept the phone. After a little while his deputy
Mr. Abdulwahhab Al-anisi called me up, trying to make up for Al-Yadoomi's
call and saying that it is an advice, not a threat but his methods are
like that.That day he asked me to present an apology related what had been
published, I did not have an objection but I saw that the threat should
be discussed first because he is a party leader and has his influence in
the area. After two days I was surprised to see in the Thowrah newspaper
that the president had ordered investigation into what was published in
Thaqafiah newspaper! And one day before that, there was an investigation
committee formed from the managerial council of Jumhooriya newspaper who
Thaqafiah is published by. The council was headed by Mr. Md. Al-Mujahid.
And the conclusion was that this novel was already published and authorized
and what the paper did was to just republish what was published already,
and the council saw that the case does not deserve the chaos and fuss caused
by those who took up the topic.
Q: Did this trigger any proceedings before
this happened?
A: Since one and a half years I
have been receiving threats either through phone or through mosques. This
was due to a previous case which was raised by some of the leaders of the
same party through the attorney chairmanship in Taiz. But the case was
saved then on the ground that the topics under discussion had been replied
to in the same paper, and it lost currency. This was before 8 months approximately.
Q: How do the court procedures take place now?
A: I see that the law in Yemen
is the only way out for all these problems. And that it should be the reference
which all should conform to. If we lose our trust in law, then we will
lose peace in general.
What is strange in this issue is that when I had gone to the court
last Tuesday I was surprised that the judge did not receive the case file
from the attorney until the end of the court session, And lots of the audience
had seen that. The other thing that surprised me is that the judge called
people by their names in the hall. We have not heard this kind of a precedent.
We objected in the court through the lawyer specialty because the court
concerned was in Taiz. It is shocking that that the judge ordered my imprisonment
until a verdict is out although I was not involved in the case at all.
These are a few observations I put in the hands of the law which should
be kept in mind to preserve the sanctity of it and to respect it.
Q: Do you think the novel contains what was
said it did in the case?
A: If in a column or an article
something insulting to a particular person was mentioned, then we as Muslims
or any Muslim for that matter would see it an insult to his religion and
will raise objections. Our religion permits to talk and discuss and advice
and we should argue till we are convinced, but what happened in that novel
is that the novel talks about a particular era of time and refers to it
as a time of cruelty and abuse for religion. It was the Imam's era. It
was a bed time and the novel expressed realities of that time, and how
the king used the religion . What happens in the novel is that a person
whose name was Numan is the hero, he was presented in a skewed manner.
He commits lots of sins and at one point of time questions God why he took
his wife away from him, that it was unfair. He does not deny the existence
of God but he was arguing with him and blaming him; This part itself shows
some faith in the sense that the person himself is an imaginary character,
not really existing in reality, so that we could take him to court. Mohammed
Abdalwali did not leave his religion but he represented it through a character's
voice in the novel. There are many such such scenes. Even in the prophet's
speech and in the Holy Quran such things occur. It is mentioned that when
a man was traveling, his food and water was lost from him; He gave up the
search, but he finally found it. Then he said to God, " you are my slave
and I am your master." The prophet said that this was said out of happiness;
Numan mentioned it in the novel in a mood of misery and hopelessness.
Q: Does this mean that the case has taken a
dimension other than that laid by the accusers?
A: The case has definitely taken
other dimensions which are neither logical nor related to Islam, but are
rather political. Some are trying to take advantage of this to serve political
aims or to avenge themselves others whom they see a threat to their benefits
or their needs. And as I said earlier, some might see in it insult to particular
persons and not to God himself. But considering people who were subjected
to strong words and insults he saw his case worse than the insult. The
paper was accused to have insulted God where the truth is that it hurt
a few persons' ego who are reckoned in the Islamic stream in Yemen.
Q: Where does Mr. Samir find himself now?
A: I find myself alone, all harassing
me. Some think I work for the sake of a particular side and some say I
seek new fame. And some see that I have actually wanted to publish such
these to insult God, therefore I find myself alone now.
Q: How do you evaluate the stance of YJS and
other media organizations?
A: I am very pleased with the stand
of the Arab Journalists Unions which dealt with my issue as a journalist
disregarding my political affiliation.
Closure of Al-Thaqafiah will be repeated in case of other newspapers.
Unfortunately, some organizations deal with the issue in double standards
despite the fact that I have not done something wrong by publishing a novel
which had been authorized by the Ministry of Information and is available
in bookshops.
Q: Does it mean that you have been wronged
for something you have nothing to do with?
A: It is a pity to say that the
newspaper has left its doors wide open for its enemies. We were thought
be one of to them and, I myself was thought to be one of those extremists.
I thought that they would stand by us should we need them. They were supposed
to defend the freedom of expression and press. Unfortunately, Al-Thaqafiah
was the only newspaper to give access to such people to write, believing
in the principle of freedom of expression. It was an attempt to bring all
viewpoints closer to one another. I never expected such treatment from
them.
Q: Is there any message you would like to give
to people?
A: I still have hope that my colleagues
will show more solidarity with Al-Thaqafiah, the newspaper which tried
to embrace all political trends.
Q: In view of such pressure, will you find
yourself obliged to seek asylum?
A: It is too early to determine
this. I believe that the country has room enough for all. If we leave it
we will give a chance for these extremists to be stronger. However, if
I discover that our judiciary system has lost its credibility and independence
I will abandon this country at any time.
Q: Was the newspaper imitated by other official
papers?
A: The official media looked at
Al-Thaqafiah from two angles. Some of them thought that it had gone beyond
convention and it needed to be stopped. Others believed that it had established
good reputation, so they decided to imitate it.
Q: Do you think that you are fighting against
some specific individuals other than demanding Justice?
A: Certainly. Those who the paper
has thrown masks of. Those have already called for in mosques for the closure
of the paper and my arrest. I think that no judge will dare go against
them because he will be considered against religion.
A well known Islamist leader called for my trial. He even criticized
the President for keeping silent. His words in the mosque against me were
circulated as a "fatwa" (religious opinion that must be followed).
Q: Was he Sheikh Abdul Majeed Al-Zindani?
A: Yes he was.
Q: What is the message you would like to send
to the press-care organizations?
A: I would like to tell all organizations
concerned with press freedom that it is not a case of a man who stood against
religion, but it is rather a case of some people who think that the freedom
of press may affect their interests.
Q: Any last words?
A: I thank the Yemen Times which
has always been an example of freedom of expression. Its founder, late
Dr. Al-Saqqaf was able to make it popular in and outside Yemen. The certificate
he was awarded with by the Press Organization in America proves that the
Yemen Times is really distinguished from the others and it respects freedom
of opinion and expressions.
Report on Law & Diplomacy Page
Moqbil
Al-Wadi'i to Yemen Times
"..news agencies took advantage
of it (Accident of Hosea Walker) to ruin the image of our peaceful movement
and put pressure on the government to come against us."
In an extensive interview with Yemen Times -to be fully published
next week- Moqbil Al-Wadi'i stressed the fact that the British student
Hosea Walker, 16, was actually killed in an accident in which no intentions
were there. According to him, the accident happened when one of his friends
was cleaning his gun, resulting in the accidental release of one bullet
which hit Hosea in his chest, resulting in his death. The Shekh of the
Salafi Islami religious movement said he was notified about the accident
in a phone call while he was in Sanaa, and that the brother of the victim
came to him and explained all the details of the accident.
Al-Wadi'i expressed his disappointment at the false information
provided by some news agencies about the news that he had a military training
camp in which he trained militant Islamists for Jihad purposes. "This
is the first such accident that happened in his institution; However, news
agencies took advantage of it to ruin the image of our peaceful movement
and put pressure on the government to go against us" he said.
In regard to allegations that he had links with other terrorist
Islamist movements such as the Islamic Jihad or Abyan Army, which led to
the death of the 3 Britons and 1 Australian in Abyan, he said that there
is no link whatsoever with these groups. "We have even condemned these
groups and called it the movements of corruption, not jihad. We always
disapprove of any violent actions to spread Islam. Islam is a religion
of peace and harmony, and such violence should never be thought of as part
of Islam" he replied.
In regard to the number of foreign students he had, he responded
by saying, "We have hundreds of students from all over the world who
have come to learn more about Islam in the appropriate manner. We have
students from the UK, the USA, Indonesia, France, Germany, etc." However,
avoiding to mention that there are more than 100,000 students who have
studied and continue to study with him, he refused to provide exact numbers
or percentages in this regard. 'What is important for us is to teach these
students the true principles of Islam, which are stronger and more powerful
than weapons and military training. On the other hand, we do not even have
the financial budget to cover the cost of any weapons we may purchase.
We are more concerned about basic needs rather than weapons."
When asked about the West he said, "The West has developed in
industry not because they left their religion, but because they gave more
importance to science, which is actually what Islam calls for. On the other
hand, we cannot fight enemies of Islam (West) if we do not have the power
and internal strength in religion and physical capabilities. Only when
we are truly strong Muslims with all military capabilities can we begin
fighting them."He then talked about the latest Jewish visits to Yemen
by saying, "I condemn these visits, and believe that a Jew and Muslim
should never live in the same country, and can never do so."The Wahabbi
Salafi movement led by Sheik Moqbil, started 20 years ago when it started
spreading all over the country, and even abroad. "In the last 10 years,
the growth of the movement has been rapid as it exceeded the Yemeni boundaries,
and its reputation increased in Europe and elsewhere. However, we face
difficulties and some harassment by some officials in the government who
attempt to take away mosques from the control of Sunnis by force."He
also confirmed the reports about the pressure exerted by other religious
institutions on the his students not to study the Salafi religious movement.
"We are the most prominent, stable, and peaceful Islamic institution
in Yemen. We cannot be compared to other institutions as we have graduated
more than 100,000 students so far, while others have much smaller number."
He added.
It is worth mentioning that the interview was full of interesting
questions and answers, and it is the first ever interview with a Yemeni
newspaper, as Sheik Moqbil always refused to be interviewed, and had no
photo of him published in any publication. As he refused to be photographed
- as he thinks it is prohibited- in this interview, we are unable to publish
a photo of his. The complete interview will hopefully be published on next
edition of Yemen Times.
|